Canada must stand up to Trump

It took less than 24 hours for Washington to prove, yet again, that it can yank Canada’s chain and make Ottawa heel.

We must say NO to bullies

On June 30, last, Canada’s finance minister François-Philippe Champagne announced that the government will scrap its modest three per cent Digital Services Tax (DST) after former U.S President Donald Trump thundered that all trade talks were “terminated” until his Silicon Valley friends were spared this pea-sized levy.

Let’s pause on that date for a moment. June 30 was the very day the first DST payments were due. Revenue Parliament had already booked to help fund everything from rural broadband to child-care spaces.

But instead of collecting a fair share from trillion-dollar tech titans, Ottawa folded in the face of a tantrum from a man who is not Canada’s head of state, and certainly not its friend. The message to every citizen is brutal and unmistakable: if you are rich, American and politically connected, Canada’s laws bend: everyone else is expected to pay up and shut up.

Mark Carney

Let us remember what the DST actually was. Three per cent, not of profits, but of Canadian-sourced revenue above a generous $20-million threshold, for companies that extract our personal data, sell us ads and remit precious little tax in return. France, Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom already impose similar or higher rates; the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development has spent years crafting a global framework to make such taxes routine. Canada’s levy was scheduled, reasonable and overdue.

Yet within hours of Trump’s sabre-rattling, the Canadian finance minister was touting “flexibility” and promising repeal legislation. Prime Minister Mark Carney, once hailed as a global finance visionary, now sounds like a schoolboy who has been told to hand over his lunch money and say thank-you.

No wonder Trump crowed that he has “so much power over Canada.” Ottawa just proved him right.

This is not a partisan failing; it is a national one. For 30 years we have been conditioned to believe that Canada’s prosperity depends on flattering the United States, even when the bully on the other side of the border spits in our face.

Remember the War of 1812? We burned the White House and defended our territory against an invasion. Today, we cannot even defend a three  per cent surcharge on Alphabet and Amazon. Our ancestors would be appalled.

Worse, capitulation feeds a dangerous myth that Canada is helpless without access to American cash registers. Facts shred that fiction. The United States accounts for barely four per cent of the world’s population; Asia, Africa and Latin America are where the middle class is exploding. China, India, Indonesia and Nigeria are minting consumers faster than America can print campaign yard signs. In 2024 China overtook the U.S. as the world’s largest economy on a purchasing-power basis; it did so without slavishly begging Washington’s approval.

Canada is not a flyspeck that must cling to a single market. We possess the planet’s third-largest proven oil reserves, vast critical-minerals deposits, the safest banking system in the G7 and a reputation for regulatory stability.

Instead of shipping raw bitumen south at a permanent discount, we could refine it in Alberta, Saskatchewan and Atlantic Canada, creating union jobs and selling gasoline, jet fuel and petrochemicals to any customer with hard currency.

Value-added production, not raw-resource dumping, built Norway’s sovereign-wealth fund; it can build ours too.

Diversification is not theory; it is already happening. Canadian wheat feeds North Africa; our uranium powers reactors from Romania to South Korea; Saskatchewan potash greens Brazil’s soy fields. Last year Vancouver’s film industry earned a record $4.2 billion renting sound stages to streaming giants who crave Canadian talent and locations. None of these customers demanded we kneel to Trump.

Consumers are ahead of politicians. Walk into any grocery store this week and watch shoppers flip jars to avoid the “Product of U.S.A.” label. Anecdotal? Perhaps. But the Canada-wide boycott of Florida orange juice during the 1991 citrus-tariff fight knocked American processors to their knees in three months. If our own government will not defend us, we will deploy our wallets.

Still, purchasing power alone is not a strategy. Ottawa must lock in four structural changes now: Legislate the DST anyway, raise it to 5 per cent in 2027 and dedicate every dollar to an Innovation Sovereignty Fund that backs Canadian digital platforms, not foreign monopolies.

Mandate domestic refining capacity for at least 50 per cent of our crude by 2030. Ship finished product east-west-north, anywhere but south, so no pipeline is a hostage to American politics.

Pivot trade promotion to the Indo-Pacific, Africa and the Caribbean, markets hungry for responsibly sourced energy, clean-tech, agri-food and professional services. Ottawa’s new free-trade office in Nairobi should receive the resources it deserves, not be treated as a diplomatic novelty.

Codify an anti-retaliation protocol: any time Washington deploys punitive tariffs outside WTO rules, Canada triggers mirror levies of equal value on U.S. luxury goods, yachts, bourbon, pickup trucks, items with concentrated political clout south of the border.

Critics will gasp that such measures risk a trade war. News flash: Trump already declared one. The question is whether we will fight back or keep insisting the bully likes us.

America’s gun-soaked, debt- laden consumer culture is not the only path to prosperity. Denmark’s per-capita GDP is higher than the United States’, and it trades far more with Europe than with America. Australia sells iron ore to China while maintaining an alliance with Washington.

Canada can build a similar multi-polar portfolio, if we choose courage over codependency.

Courage begins with language. Stop calling ourselves a “middle power”, the phrase drips with insecurity. We are a Pacific and Atlantic power, an Arctic power, a renewable-energy power and an agrifood power. The DST humiliation is a reminder that others will rate us only as highly as we rate ourselves.

So let us rewrite the script. Ottawa should announce tomorrow that the Digital Services Tax suspension is temporary pending public consultations, and then run those consultations straight through the U.S. election cycle. If Trump is re-elected, the tax snaps back automatically at five per cent plus interest. If a more reasonable administration emerges, Canada can negotiate multilaterally at the OECD table, not bilaterally under a pistol. Either way, the decision remains ours.

In 1867 Sir George-Étienne Cartier said Confederation would ensure “a political nationality with which neither the national origin, nor the religion of any individual, would interfere.”

Replace “religion” with “foreign intimidation” and the principle still stands. Our sovereignty is not a chip to be traded for short-term export receipts, nor is it a privilege bestowed by American approval. It is a birthright, paid for at Queenston Heights, Vimy Ridge and Juno Beach, and sustained every day by the work of 40 million Canadians who pay taxes without special pleading.

The next time Donald Trump—or any U.S. president—insists that Canada abandon a duly enacted law that corrects a glaring market failure, the proper answer is not “How high?” but “Goodbye.” The world is wide, the future is digital and power belongs to those prepared to claim it.

Three per cent was never about revenue; it was about respect. Canada just lost that round. Let’s make sure we never lose another.

Anthony Joseph is the publisher of The Caribbean Camera newspaper. He writes on politics, culture, and the intersection of race and democracy in Canada.

 


You must be logged in to post a comment Login